Bartons Pizzeria in Schererville, IN with Reviews -
Book appointments, post photos, and write reviews.Open in YP App
By: N. L.
Giuseppe's Pizza
Best pizza in the area. Owned and operated by Italian Americans. Nona still works part time in the kitchen. Ben there many times and never had a bad experience.
user avatar
By: Katie H.
Rosati's Pizza
The pizza is pretty good, but the service I received from an employees at the Schererville location was horrible. My husband ordered a pizza online and paid for it. Because of circumstances, I was unable to pick it up until right before closing. I walked in at 9:57pm. As soon as a walked in the door, a middle aged blondish lady yelled rudely at me, "WE'RE CLOSED!" (Technically not, since they close at 10:00pm.) . I said that I had a pizza to pick up. She yelled again, "I don't have any pizza's left!!" Bewildered, I said, "Well, my husband ordered a pizza..." "I don't have any pizzas left!!" She interupted. Trying to figure out was happened, I stated again that my husband did order a pizza and paid for it, and this was the only Rosati's that I know of. She said something like, "There are other locations, but I don't have any pizzas and I'm closed, so I can't help you!" I walked out. She was extremely rude and unhelpful. Turned out my husband got the Schererville and Crown Point locations mixed up, and out pizza was in Crown Point. I called that location, telling them about the mix up, and I knew they were closed, but could I still pick it up? The manager in Crown Point was very sweet and helpful, said she would wait for me, and it was no problem. I understand that it was late and the mistake was on our part, but that employee in Schererville was horribly rude, unprofessional, unhelpful, and has no business speaking to anyone like she did, much less a customer with a problem. If you want Rosati's pizza, I recommend the Crown Point location. I'm pretty sure their pizza was better too.
By: Thomas B.
Aurelio's Pizza
We have been eating Aurelio's pizza from this location for more than 25 years. Definitely the best pizza in the area!
user avatar
By: Cassie J.
Pizza Hut
When they hit "peak hours" the orders go through a call center with people who don't speak English!!! I got a burnt pizza and tried to get a replacement. I couldn't get direcred to the store through THIS number!!!!!! Had to drive back.
By: Chris P.
I'd rather keep my 5 bucks.
By: Chris P.
Smashmouth Burgers & Pizza
This was one of the worst hamburger joints I've ever been to Burger King has a better hamburger.
By: Frankie C.
Smashmouth Burgers & Pizza
This is the place for it all! The monster burger is nothing much to look at, however ..... WOW! Most excellent!! The beef brisket sandwich is a work of art! Definitely try this place out! I can't wait to go back!
By: clayton.morgan.90
Rosati's Pizza
Rosatis pizza is really good. not greasy like the speed chain pizza places.fried mushrooms were good. they just forgot to give delivery guy some ketchup for me
By: patti.lejeune
Smashmouth Burgers & Pizza
The burgers and the chicken I know are fantastic but the smoked beef brisket is off the hook. I would crawl on gravel to get there for it.

Just a moment...