East Of Chicago Pizza Locations & Hours Near Reynoldsburg, OH - YP.com
Book appointments, post photos, and write reviews.Open in YP App

Temporary Error.

Please try reloading the page.

user avatar
By: George A.
Vick's Gourmet Pizza
Great Pizza and friendly atmosphere. I can't wait until they move into the old Connell Hardware building on the same block. They're moving in there for more dinning space and easier access
user avatar
By: George A.
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
The one time I ordered a pizza from them, they forgot to put the sauce on it. Never went back, never will. I go to Vick's, Grandma's or Pizzaroni's for me when it comes to Pizza in Reynoldsburg.
By: Rhoda S.
Grandma's Pizza & Pasta
Ordered from them twice and both times our order was f---ed up. Food cold, soggy slimy bread, long ass wait 1 hr and 6 minutes? And we are just minutes away? We will not be giving them our service anymore!!!!!!!!!!
By: Larry S.
Classic Pizza
My son came home from the service and wanted classic pizza last week. We grew up on it. We went there and got pizza and a 16 inch sub. The bun on the sub was so hard we couldn't eat it and oh my the pizza was just down right nasty. I think I seen mold in the cheese, the crust was gooey but burnt on the sides and the girl that served it to us was playing with her hair the whole time she was making food. I think she had her whole family in there. Someone needs to call the health department on that place. We will never go back or will my friends
By: holmez80
Classic Pizza
So I just had classic pizza from the Reynoldsburg location. I grew up on classic pizza and this was not it. So they changed the cheese, the pepperoni was not to par and the sauce not there, either. Needless to say, if you love classic pizza don't waste your money here.
By: Ross R.
Good pizza fare price friendly people a must try place
By: blueeyes7
Vick's Gourmet Pizza
AWESOME, and so so yummy.Vick's is the Best Pizza, Subs,, Wings, Strombolli's, etc, everything is amazing. You can not go wrong at all, the #1 Best Pizza Place in Reynoldsburg, Ohio on Main St.Must try, You'll Love them
By: scottomac10
Best pizza in Reynoldsburg,
By: vleake
Best wings I have had in Columbus, and the Cream Puffs are to die for.Can't wait till go back
user avatar
By: mrjleew
Donatos Pizza
This location taught me to always look at your pizza before you leave. When I got home and opened the box, I got a big surprise, my pizza looked like it had been dropped. All the pepperoni was on one side and it looked like some was missing. Well, I called back, told my story, was told to come back or when I order again I would have a credit. Needless to say I never got the credit. Called their Corporate office and was given the runner-round.

Just a moment...