Best 30 Italian Restaurants in Erie, Pennsylvania with Reviews -

Temporary Error.

Please try reloading the page.

user avatar
By: Mary S.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
I ordered out. First time. Service was good. Food was poor. Alfredo sauce was under seasoned or not seasoned at all. The Chicken was great tender and moist. The bread sticks had no garlic butter on them and by the time I finished the first one it became crisp and hard, possibly over warmed in the microwave. I have eaten in many times and was very satisfied BUT I was very disappointed with my Alfredo part of my meal. I am thankful for the chicken. I hope the salad lives up to its reputation. I'm sorry I'm just being honest. I doubt I will ever order out again. I will eat in but be leary of the Alfredo sauce. I said I hoped that the salad would live up to its reputation and it did for the most part, check out the picture of some of the lettuce:I guess if it wasn't for the chicken the whole meal would have been a complete waste. I spent $16.00 to have some chicken. Lesson learned. Eat in if you want a good meal.
user avatar
By: Alexandria Y.
Valerio's Italian Restaurant
I ordered lunch from here today as I do quite often and I am usually quite satisfied. Today however, I ordered the soup and salad deal and asked for extra ranch dressing this took about an hour. I then gave the person taking my order the directions to my building and they asked if it was okay for the driver to call when he got there. I said fine. The driver calls and I give him the directions. He doesn't show up. I call him back and he swears he's here. So it gets cleared up he just went to the wrong building. That's totally fine! Mistakes happen. What is not fine is the attitude that I got when he finally got there. He huffed and groaned. Ugh! Oh. They also forgot my Italian bread.
By: Linda T.
Alto Cucina
Last week a friend and I experienced a lovely night at Alto Cucina....wonderful staff, excellent service, ahi tuna was the best that I have had in this area.......generous portion and absolutely shelf tuna!! The bartender Kevin was very personable and made a great martini. Erik, our waiter is very experienced and exhibits just the right amount of attention to patrons. Atmosphere is so right...........cannot say enough about this restaurant......a superb dining experience.
By: jeneria
Mi Scuzi Ristorante Italiano
Mi Scuzi is head and shoulders above what it used to be! I absolutely love the food here, this is definitely my favorite place to eat in Erie. We had my sister's rehearsal dinner here recently, and it was so good that I brought my friends in to eat the very next weekend (and almost every weekend since). HIGHLY recommend!
By: johncalabresetreiber
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
If you're like me and enjoy VERY large portion sizes of great Italian food, you will love Olive Garden. Everything from the garlic breadsticks to the zuppa toscana is the next best thing from homemades! All this for a great price and super service. This Olive Garden is one of the best managed I've seen.
By: imp558
Barbato's Italian Restaurant
Nice family style italian resteraunt, staff is great, prices are reasonable, and there's a buffett on Fri and Sat that is a really good value. They run out of wedding soup and don't prepare more quickly enough but it's all forgiven in the form of a tub of pepperoni balls.
By: pncpark2k1
Barbatos Italian Restaurant
Don't let the location fool you, when you walk in the door you think of this place is kinda cute, but when you get the food and see the price is your blown away, I will be eating here on many of my trips to Erie, especially the buffet.
user avatar
By: Elizabeth W.
We get takeout here all the time. It's amazing food for a great price!!! I love this place! If you want good Italian and reasonable portions and prices this is the perfect place!
By: johncalabresetreiber
Valerio's Italian Restaurant
Calzones are the best in town. If you eat in the service is very friendly.
By: Natalie S.
Barbatos Italian Restaurant
Great food and great service! Best Alfredo sauce ever! Don't pass it up!

Just a moment...