I would give this restaurant a 0 rating if it was possible. Several of the BBQ teams that participated in the Almost Heaven BBQ Bash held in Buckhannon on 6/20/15 decided to go there for dinner that evening. There were 22 of us looking for someplace to have some good food and a few drinks with friends. Obviously we went to the wrong place. They placed us in a private room on a separate floor from the main dining room. We were told by a person outside of this restaurant that this is supposed to be their 'party room', but apparently that term only applies if you are having a tea party or other similarly quiet and sober occasion. We had only had time for one round of drinks when the waitress came in and told us that the manager had said that we were no longer allowed to have any liquor. When asked, we were told it was because we were being too loud and obnoxious. I will admit that we may have been loud, but would it have been so hard to simply ask us to tone it down? We weren't even given a chance. Nothing at all had been said to us prior to us being told we could no longer have anything but beer. We tried to talk to the manager, but he wasn't interested in anything any of us had to say, and in fact was incredibly rude and got a very nasty attitude towards us. He told us bluntly that he didn't want our business, so we will honor his wishes and make sure that neither we, nor anyone we know, ever steps foot in his establishment again.
The last time I went to C J Maggie's, I ordered the vegetarian pasta, it was a mistake. The pasta and vegetables was full of water and the seasoning was horrible, It was close to being inedible. Also, the service was extremely slow, we had to wait an hour for our food. For being the only American restaurant in Buckhannon, you think that they would try a little harder to be the best that they can be. I know that the next time, if there is a next time, I will be very cautious as to what I order and take the least amount of people with me, in the hopes that the food arrives better and faster.